Whether a fade or draw is better is a question that has been debated for many years among golfers and instructors. While top amateurs and tour pros have the ability to curve the ball either way they generally rely on one preferred ball flight. There are advantages and disadvantages to both which I will discuss in this article.
Advantages of hitting a draw.
Distance – Generally a draw creates more distance than a fade because of the lower, penetrating ball flight and increased roll. This is especially true with the driver.
Windy Conditions – A draw is more preferable in windy conditions because the lower ball flight cuts through headwinds better than a high flying fade. It’s also easier to control distance with approach shots when you can keep the ball under the wind.
Doglegs to the left – The right to left curvature of a draw naturally fits the design of a hole that bends to the left and will generally leave the player closer to the green.
Access to left pin positions – A draw is a preferred shot when the pin is located on the left of the green. A player may start the ball at the center of the green anticipating the ball curving toward the hole. Even if the ball flies straight the player is still on the center of the green with a chance to make birdie. He has also eliminated the chance missing the green left and short siding himself.
Takes the right side of the course out of play – Having the ability to hit a consistent draw takes the right side of the course out of play including hazards and out of bounds.
Advantages of hitting a fade.
More control and accuracy – A fade flies higher, creates more backspin and lands more softly which allows for more control on approach shots especially on firm greens. A fade also doesn’t need as much wrist action and timing as required with a draw so consistency is usually better.
Doglegs to the right – The left to right curvature of a fade naturally fits the design of a hole that bends to the right and will generally leave the player closer to the green.
Access to right pin positions – A fade is a preferred shot when the pin is located on the right of the green. A player may start the ball at the center of the green anticipating the ball curving toward the hole. Even is the ball flies straight the player is still on the center of the green with a chance to make birdie. He has also eliminated the chance of missing the green right and short siding himself.
Takes the left side of the course out of play – Having the ability to hit a consistent fade takes the left side of the course out of play including hazard and out of bounds.
Certainly having the ability to shape shots in both directions gives you the most versatility and control. My observation and experience is that most top amateurs and tour pros favor a fade off the tee because it is easier to repeat and therefore is more consistent. Two great examples would be Jack Nicklaus and Tiger Woods. Both players could obviously could work the ball both ways. but preferred a fade with their driver because they were more concerned with control than a few extra yards.
The key to playing well is improving your consistency. By having a “stock shot” whether it be a fade or draw not only allows you to take one side of the course out of play, but also leads to more consistency. If you need help find an instructor that can help you develop a “go to” shot and you will soon be shooting lower scores.